Thursday, December 5, 2013

Old boy (2003)

Also Known As: -
Year of first release: 2003
Director: Chanwook Park
Actors: Min-sik Choi, Hye-jeong Kang, Ji-tae Yu
Country: ROK
Genre: Action
Conditions of visioning: 03.12.2013, DVD
Synopsis: An average man is kidnapped and imprisoned in a shabby cell for 15 years without explanation. He then is released, equipped with money, a cellphone and expensive clothes. As he strives to explain his imprisonment and get his revenge, Oh Dae-Su soon finds out that his kidnapper has a greater plan for him and is set onto a path of pain and suffering in an attempt to uncover the motive of his mysterious tormentor.
Review: I did well to watch the original just after the remake. The story is really good and revolutionary. It questions "I am a monster, but I have the right to live". And actually we see really two crazy monsters in this movie. The philosophical questions are omnipresent, while they completely disappeared from the Spike Lee remake. The heroe is an average man and behaves all along as such, which makes it closer from the viewer. This way we can more easily take his place, while in the Lee version, the heroe is like a superheroe and therefore not interesting in this movie. The Korean movie has some great scenes for the originality ("I need to eat something alive", the hammer scene) and for the directing (hammer scene) but also several lacking of better technology or time and looking therefore very cheap. The ending of the movie is very Asian, explaining the rationale with an off voice, and very cruel and revolutionary for its content. No movie would depict (SPOILER) and destroy with no mercy the heroe this way! If no scene would look cheap as it does several times, this could have become a master piece.
Rating: 8 /10

Additional bonus point for the Korean movie, the posters are much more esthetic. See some other ones below. 

2 comments:

  1. I also loved this original and strong movie the first time I saw it. A you write, we witness the reactions of an ordinary man to forced emprisonment without explanation. The unfortunate "too asian" scenes would make me rate it 8/10 as well, while it could have gotten more.
    For me the best example of an asian movie that manages to show a local story but that everybody in the world can relate to is Memories of Murder, a masterpiece.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree, Memories of murder is a masterpiece. And I am therefore impatient to watch Snowpiercer.

    ReplyDelete